Skip to content
Tabifolk logo
  • Home
  • Find Groups
  • Destinations
    • Africa
      • General
      • Kenya
      • South Africa
    • Asia
      • General
      • China
      • India
      • Indonesia
      • Japan
      • Nepal
      • Philippines
      • Singapore
      • South Korea
      • Sri Lanka
      • Taiwan
      • Thailand
      • Vietnam
    • Europe
      • General
      • Austria
      • Belgium
      • Estonia
      • France
      • Germany
      • Greece
      • Ireland
      • Italy
      • Netherlands
      • Poland
      • Portugal
      • Romania
      • Spain
      • Sweden
      • Switzerland
      • United Kingdom
    • Middle East
      • General
      • Egypt
      • Israel
      • Türkiye
      • United Arab Emirates
    • Oceania
      • Australia
      • New Zealand
    • North America
      • General
      • Canada
      • Caribbean
      • United States
    • South America
      • General
      • Brazil
      • Colombia
  • Topics
    • General Discussions
    • Silver Travel
    • Accessible Cruises
    • Flying with a Disability
    • Riding the Rails
    • Devices and Technology
    • Accessible Rental Properties
    • Neurodiverse Travel
    • Sensory Friendly Travel
    • Accessible Theme Parks
    • Accessible Disney
    • Traveling with Special Needs Children
    • Travel with Assistance Animals
    • Travel with an Invisible Disability
    • Travelers with Hearing Impairments
    • Travelers with Visual Impairments
    • Traveling with Chronic Pain / Illness
    • Discover More…
  • tabifolk talks
  • Blog
    Sign in Sign up
    Tabifolk logo
    Tabifolk logo
    • Home
    • Browse Groups
    • Trouble With Me Podcast
    • Log In
    • Register
      • Profile Photo
        Profile photo of Josh Grisdale
        Accessible Travel Academy
        Josh Grisdale 4 years ago

        Of all the places offering mapping services for people with disabilities that already exist, I’m not sure why they were featured in Forbes since there doesn’t seem to be any data yet(!), but they were: https://www.forbes.com/sites/peterslatin/2020/07/27/after-30-years-making-accessibility-information-accessible/#6e7d1ac638ee

        However, something I thought was interesting was they make an argument *against* crowd sourcing for an accessibility mapping service. Do you agree? Or should all services be crowd sourced? Or maybe a hybrid approach is best (ie a set of criteria in the listing supplemented with user-generated content)…?

        What do you think?

        forbes.com

        After 30 Years, Making Accessibility Information Accessible

        “We aren’t here to talk about compliance. We’re here to talk about what exists today – and in the future. If businesses provide information about the features they do have–based on ADA guidelines–then the person with a disability can make … Continue reading

        2 Comments
        • Profile photo of pieterghijsels
          pieterghijsels

          You raise an interesting matter, Josh. If I’m reading the article well, the interviewees compare crowd-sourcing to self-assessment by the proprietor. Actually, there’s a third method: screenings by an external professional agency. All these methods have their strengths and flaws.

          Self-assessment by the owner and crowd-sourcing both have a more personal aspect, as they both involve a directly interested party – either the supplier or the customer/visitor, while an external auditor will (hopefully) try to avoid anything that’s too biased. It’s like when a film director will talk about their latest movie, compared to a viewer and a film critic.

          Crowd-sourcing gives people something to commit to, it’s personal and it’s probably cheaper to organise, compared to professional screenings (if you don’t count the costs to keep people motivated). For this and other reasons, crowd-sourcing will be interesting when you want to cover a large amount of audits in a short time, like on an action day.

          On the other hand, a professional screener will be more accountable for their work, and they can be expected to make a more thorough analysis considering a variety of accessibility requirements. The screenings are also easier to harmonise and to coordinate if you’re working with only a limited number of screeners.

          If there’s a budget available, I think that a combination of methods would be best in the long run. Crowd-sourcing can give you an indication of where you’ll want more details. People will be happy to keep an eye out for any outdated information, if you provide a feedback tool. Likewise, it’s not unusual to ask a proprietor some basic information before an external agency gets involved. But I’d certainly prefer paid researchers if the screenings have any official consequences (certification, grants, etc).

          4 years ago
          • Profile photo of Josh Grisdale
            Josh Grisdale

            I like the film director, viewer and film critic idea – well put!

            I wonder what @bookman  has to say – he has a crowd-sourced project.

            4 years ago
      • Public
      • All Members
      • My Tabi Contacts
      • Only Me
      • Public
      • All Members
      • My Tabi Contacts
      • Only Me
      • Public
      • All Members
      • My Tabi Contacts
      • Only Me
      Tabifolk logo
      • About Us
      • Advertise on tabifolk
      • Terms
      • Privacy
      • Commercial Disclosure
      • Cookies
      • Ad Tracking
      • California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) Opt-Out IconYour Privacy Choices
      • Notice at Collection

      If you like what we do, help us grow the community by telling others!

      © 2025 - tabiLabs Inc  
      Sign inSign up
      Home
      My Groups
      My Discussions
      News Feed

      Report

      There was a problem reporting this post.

      Harassment or bullying behavior
      Contains mature or sensitive content
      Contains misleading or false information
      Contains abusive or derogatory content
      Contains spam, fake content or potential malware

      Block Member?

      Please confirm you want to block this member.

      You will no longer be able to:

      • See blocked member's posts
      • Mention this member in posts
      • Invite this member to groups
      • Message this member
      • Add this member as a connection

      Please note: This action will also remove this member from your connections and send a report to the site admin. Please allow a few minutes for this process to complete.

      Report

      You have already reported this .